Fantastic Stars Ratings

How many stars out of a Fantastic Four stars would you give this issue?

Here’s a nice running total of our ratings of each and every issue in the Marvel Universe.

Vinnie’s ratings

Fantastic Four Stars

Tales To Astonish No. 27 (Ant-Man)
Amazing Fantasy No. 15 (Spider-Man)
Fantastic Four No. 6
Tales To Astonish No. 39 (Ant-Man)
Tales Of Suspense No. 39 (Iron Man)
Amazing Spider-Man No. 1
Fantastic Four No. 13
Amazing Spider-Man No. 3
Strange Tales No. 110 (Doctor Strange)
Strange Tales No. 111 (Doctor Strange)
Fantastic Four No. 16
Fantastic Four No. 17
Amazing Spider-Man No. 4
X-Men No. 1
Amazing Spider-Man No. 5
Fantastic Four Annual No. 1
Amazing Spider-Man No. 6
Amazing Spider-Man No. 7
Fantastic Four No. 21
Strange Tales No. 116 (Doctor Strange)
Amazing Spider-Man No. 9
Amazing Spider-Man No. 12
Amazing Spider-Man No. 13
Fantastic Four No. 25
Avengers No. 5

Fantastic Three Stars

Fantastic Four No. 1
Fantastic Four No. 2
Fantastic Four No. 5
Tales To Astonish No. 35 (Ant-Man)
Journey Into Mystery No. 85 (Thor)
Journey Into Mystery No. 86 (Thor)
Strange Tales No. 104 (Human Torch)
Fantastic Four No. 10
Fantastic Four No. 12
Fantastic Four No. 14
Tales To Astonish No. 45 (Ant-Man)
Fantastic Four No. 18
Tales Of Suspense No. 46 (Iron Man)
Fantastic Four No. 20
Avengers No. 2
Strange Tales No. 115 (Doctor Strange)
Journey Into Mystery No. 103 (Thor)
Journey Into Mystery No. 104 (Thor)
Fantastic Four No. 22
Strange Tales No. 117 (Doctor Strange)
Fantastic Four No. 23
X-Men No. 4
Daredevil No. 1
Tales Of Suspense No. 52 (Iron Man)
Strange Tales No. 120 (Doctor Strange)
Fantastic Four No. 26

Fantastic Two Stars

Fantastic Four No. 4
Journey Into Mystery No. 83 (Thor)
Journey Into Mystery No. 84 (Thor)
Tales To Astonish No. 38 (Ant-Man)
Tales To Astonish No. 41 (Ant-Man)
Journey Into Mystery No. 92 (Thor)
Tales To Astonish No. 44 (Ant-Man)
Avengers No. 1
Fantastic Four No. 19
X-Men No. 2
Tales Of Suspense No. 49 (Iron Man)
Tales To Astonish No. 49 (Ant-Man)
Journey Into Mystery No. 99 (Thor)
Journey Into Mystery No. 100 (Thor)
Journey Into Mystery No. 101 (Thor)
Journey Into Mystery No. 102 (Thor)
Avengers No. 3
X-Men No. 3
Avengers No. 4
Tales Of Suspense No. 50 (Iron Man)
Amazing Spider-Man No. 11
X-Men No. 5
Avengers No. 6

Fantastic One Stars

Fantastic Four No. 3
Incredible Hulk No. 1
Fantastic Four No. 7
Tales To Astonish No. 36 (Ant-Man)
Incredible Hulk No. 4
Fantastic Four No. 8
Journey Into Mystery No. 88 (Thor)
Amazing Spider-Man No. 2
Journey Into Mystery No. 93 (Thor)
Tales Of Suspense No. 42 (Iron Man)
Fantastic Four No. 15
Tales To Astonish No. 48 (Ant-Man)
Tales To Astonish No. 50 (Ant-Man)
Tales To Astonish No. 51 (Ant-Man)
Tales Of Suspense No. 49 (Ant-Man)
Strange Tales No. 118 (Doctor Strange)
Strange Tales No. 119 (Doctor Strange)
Tales To Astonish No. 52 (Ant-Man)
Tales Of Suspense No. 53 (Iron Man)
Tales Of Suspense No. 54 (Iron Man)
Tales Of Suspense No. 55 (Iron Man)

Fantastic Zero Stars

Incredible Hulk No. 2
Incredible Hulk No. 3
Fantastic Four No. 9
Incredible Hulk No. 5
Fantastic Four No. 11
Incredible Hulk No. 6
Tales Of Suspense No. 40 (Iron Man)
Tales Of Suspense No. 41 (Iron Man)
Amazing Spider-Man No. 8
Fantastic Four No. 24
Tales Of Suspense No. 51 (Iron Man)
Tales To Astonish No. 53 (Ant-Man)

Charlie’s ratings (with all those ridiculous decimal points)

4.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 5
4.0 stars – Amazing Fantasy No. 15 (Spider-Man)
4.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 6
4.0 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 39 (Ant-Man)
4.0 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 3
4.0 stars – Fantastic Four Annual No. 1
4.0 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 6
4.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 21
4.0 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 9
3.9 stars – Fantastic Four No. 13
3.9 stars – Fantastic Four No. 17
3.9 stars – Fantastic Four No. 25
3.8 stars – Fantastic Four No. 10
3.8 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 1
3.8 stars – Strange Tales No. 110 (Doctor Strange)
3.8 stars – Fantastic Four No. 16
3.8 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 5
3.8 stars – Fantastic Four No. 20
3.8 stars – Strange Tales No. 115 (Doctor Strange)
3.8 stars – Strange Tales No. 116 (Doctor Strange)
3.8 stars – Fantastic Four No. 23
3.8 stars – X-Men No. 4
3.8 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 12
3.8 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 13
3.75 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 85 (Thor)
3.75 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 39 (Iron Man)
3.75 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 104 (Thor)
3.7 stars – Fantastic Four No. 12
3.6 stars – X-Men No. 1
3.6 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 7
3.5 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 27 (Ant-Man)
3.5 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 4
3.5 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 11
3.5 stars – Fantastic Four No. 26
3.4 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 35 (Ant-Man)
3.4 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 45 (Ant-Man)
3.4 stars – Fantastic Four No. 22
3.3 stars – Fantastic Four No. 2
3.3 stars – Strange Tales No. 111 (Doctor Strange)
3.3 stars – Avengers No. 2
3.3 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 103 (Thor)
3.3 stars – Daredevil No. 1
3.3 stars – Avengers No. 5
3.2 stars – Strange Tales No. 104 (Human Torch)
3.2 stars – Fantastic Four No. 14
3.2 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 101 (Thor)
3.2 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 102 (Thor)
3. 2 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 52 (Iron Man)
3.1 stars – Fantastic Four No. 18
3.1 stars – Strange Tales No. 118 (Doctor Strange)
3.1 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 52 (Ant-Man)
3.1 stars – Strange Tales No. 120 (Doctor Strange)
3.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 1
3.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 4
3.0 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 86 (Thor)
3.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 19
3.0 stars – Avengers No. 6
2.9 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 36 (Ant-Man)
2.9 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 44 (Ant-Man)
2.9 stars – Strange Tales No. 117 (Doctor Strange)
2.8 stars – Fantastic Four No. 7
2.8 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 48 (Ant-Man)
2.75 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 99 (Thor)
2.75 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 100 (Thor)
2.7 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 38 (Ant-Man)
2.6 stars – Incredible Hulk No. 1
2.6 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 84 (Thor)
2.6 stars – Avengers No. 3
2.6 stars – Strange Tales No. 119 (Doctor Strange)
2.5 stars – Avengers No. 4
2.5 stars – X-Men No. 5
2.3 stars – X-Men No. 2
2.3 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 49 (Ant-Man)
2.2 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 83 (Thor)
2.2 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 49 (Iron Man)
2.1 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 50 (Iron Man)
2.0 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 88 (Thor)
2.0 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 41 (Ant-Man)
2.0 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 92 (Thor)
2.0 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 46 (Iron Man)
1.7 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 2
1.7 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 55 (Iron Man)
1.6 stars – Avengers No. 1
1.5 stars – Journey Into Mystery No. 93 (Thor)
1.5 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 54 (Iron Man)
1.4 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 53 (Iron Man)
1.2 stars – X-Men No. 3
1.1 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 40 (Iron Man)
1.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 3
1.0 stars – Incredible Hulk No. 4
1.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 8
1.0 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 42 (Iron Man)
1.0 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 50 (Ant-Man)
1.0 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 51 (Ant-Man)
1.0 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 49 (Iron Man)
0.7 stars – Fantastic Four No. 9
0.7 stars – Tales Of Suspense No. 41 (Iron Man)
0.6 stars – Amazing Spider-Man No. 8
0.5 stars – Incredible Hulk No. 5
0.5 stars – Fantastic Four No. 11
0.5 stars – Tales To Astonish No. 53 (Ant-Man)
0.3 stars – Fantastic Four No. 15
0.2 stars – Incredible Hulk No. 2
0.1 stars – Incredible Hulk No. 6
0.0 stars – Incredible Hulk No. 3
0.0 stars – Fantastic Four No. 24
-0.3 starts – Tales Of Suspense No. 51 (Iron Man)